State Farm® Insurance Agent Nick Koeteman
Leave Us a Review
Our customers are the center of our universe and we’re grateful for them. If you’re willing to share your experience about your interaction with our agency, it’ll be a great help for other people looking to make smart and confident decisions about their insurance and financial services.
Take 60 seconds (or more if you want) to share your story by clicking on one of the review links below.
What our customers say about us...
Renee Graff
June 11, 2026
"Nick is always prompt and so helpful. He makes situations seem less stressful. I appreciate his professionalism and help. I will always recommend him and State Farm !"
Brad Scroggins
June 10, 2026
"Nick Koteman and State Farm are the insurance equivalent of a greasy used car salesman at best. Not an agent at all. He has no answers to questions, and no authority to do anything but sell you an overpriced product.
After being a State Farm customer that has never been late on a payment and only took out more policies over the course of the close to 15 years of carrying coverage, my experience making my first claims has been an absolute nightmare. I have zero faith in State Farm to handle a claim on policies such as home or life after the way claims on a vehicle have been handled.
I am currently 8 months in to open claims.
After I had a body shop provide an estimate and returned it to State Farm, claims were opened. Over a months time went by with no correspondence. I checked in on progress but the claims had been fumbled somewhere along the line and were just getting started. I was told that State Farm did not have an adjuster in the area to look at the vehicle but that an "estimation team" would look at the claim. A second trip to the body shop was required bc the first 50+ pictures taken by the body shop, and the agent himself, of the damage to the vehicle was not satisfactory for their estimation team. State Farms estimation team managed to work up their own estimate off of pictures that weren't good enough the first time around yet no one from State Farm beside the agent himself looked at the vehicle.
A joke of a payment, just big enough to automatically take my deductible out of, was finally issued on each claim. From there State Farm treated the claims like they were finished. They had made their payment. No correspondence outside of a letter with the check that "confirmed a conversation" that i never had.
After calling the claims department and asking to speak with a manager to explain the partial payments, I was told there was no manager on shift and I would be put on a call back list. After speaking with my agent about this he provided me with the claims manager and the estimation team managers contact information. I called both. Neither answered or returned my message. After refusing to accept the partial payment as settlement and months passed again, the only way I made any progress was to check in, in person. I recently received notification that a "supplementary payment" was issued. After waiting for the check to arrive for almost a month with no correspondence i reached out to be informed the check was issued to the body shop without my knowledge or approval. No work has been preformed. The work has not even been scheduled. The 2 payments combined are just over 45% of the estimate provided let alone anthing that comes along once work is begun.
Seems to me the only thing State Farm is good at is collecting a payment. Ive never had a problem with them collecting my money."
Raegan Mueller
May 26, 2026
"I have been a customer with Nick Koeteman’s office since I was 16 years old. I had never had a claim with State Farm until last month, when my boat needed a new lower unit due to a collision with something under water. I filed a claim with State Farm and received a call within a couple hours from the claims department. I got the claims department the photos and estimate that they requested and was issued an electronic payment within 24 hours of filing a claim. Great service, and was able to get our boat going again before the next weekend! Thanks, State Farm!!"
Julie Dreier
April 1, 2026
"Nick is the best. Always helpful and the rest of the staff too, friendly service."
"Thanks, Julie! It is a blessing to be able to care for your family!!"
Nancy Murphy
June 18, 2024
"I truly appreciate State Farm agent, Nick, who forever uses professional attitude to listen, answer any questions, be patient, and lend helping hand when needed. I have NO quarrel with Nick or employees. Ashley is a dear person who always gives me extremely clear details. Actually, I am NOT upset at Nick, Ashley, or office rather I am just amazed at the cost of insurance. I am my own advocate and do ask a lot of questions."
"Thanks so much for the kind words, Nancy! We are so thankful for the opportunity to help!"
Sarah Miller
November 27, 2023
"Very happy with the service I've received from Nick's office! Never any problems!"
"Thanks so much for the kind words, Sarah! We are thankful for the opportunity and appreciate you trusting us to help!!"
Kasey Ebling
October 1, 2023
"Awesome Insurance Company!"
"Thanks so much, Kasey!! We are thankful for the opportunity to help!"
Angela Mckinnon
August 22, 2023
"Nick & Raegan always go above and beyond."
Colleen McKay
August 24, 2022
"Nick and his staff are very easy to work with and easy to talk to. Absolutely phenomenal business. Extra kudos to Ebony! - Nancy McKay"
"Thanks so much, Nancy! We are blessed to have the opportunity to take care of your wonderful family. I will make sure Ebony knows you sent kudos her way!"
Ray Mason
January 26, 2022
"Nick and his team have some of the best customer service I have seen!! They like to get to know you as a person not just a policy number."
"Thanks for the review, Ray! We appreciate your loyalty to State Farm and thank you for giving us the opportunity to take care of your family for so many years!!"
Travis & Jenna Wells
January 19, 2022
"Everyone in the office is so helpful! Anytime I ask a question, I have a response within five minutes. Professional, friendly, knowledgeable staff. I would highly recommend their office for all your insurance needs!"
"Thank you so much! We appreciate you trusting us and thank you for allowing us to help!"
Dave Barnes
October 12, 2021
"very friendly people and knowledgeable. great place to get your insurance needs!!"
"Thank you so much! We are privileged to help."
Annelise Puett
June 22, 2021
"Nick + team are the best of the best. Always willing to help with any questions or concerns, big or small. Thank you Nick!"
"Thanks so much, Annelise! We appreciate the kind words and feel blessed to be able to help!"
Pat Mujica
February 19, 2021
"I love Nick.. he will bend over backwards to get a deal done"
"Thanks so much for being patient as we worked through our system outage, Pat! We appreciate you!!"
Adam Salem
September 23, 2019
"Would highly recommend. Easy to work with staff and great auto insurance prices."
Kelly
June 28, 2019
"I am so glad that I picked Nick Koeteman as my State Farm agent when I moved to the area. All my interactions with the people in this office have been remarkably positive. They’ve been so awesome about helping me get everything transferred, answering my questions, and overall being helpful and pleasant! They were also impressively prompt in helping me get everything set up. I definitely recommend this office to anyone needing a new agent!"
John Bangerter
October 16, 2018
"Very curtious, and professional!"
David Dudeck
January 14, 2015
"Sometimes it seems like insurance companies, and insurance agents, are a dime a dozen. But the importance of good insurance and a good agent can make the decision in picking one stressful. Hopefully this review will help make your decision easier!
Nick's office in St. Joseph, MO is literally a one stop shop for all your insurance and financial needs. I have Auto/Home/Rental/Life insurance through Nick, as well as several financial products, and I couldn't be happier with State Farm and Nick's service. Nick is extremely helpful, and always wants to get you the best insurance for your needs, without over-selling you on stuff you don't really need. I've had to file a few claims, and they were handled very quickly, very professionally and with zero hassle on me. State Farm, as a company, is the best in my opinion. Nick and his team make it even better. I always recommend Nick to my friends for both personal and business insurance needs. He always come through with awesome service and really just an authentic passion for helping people."